Diogo Dalot in a Manchester United red shirt standing over the ball on the pitch under the floodlights

Diogo Dalot’s Inconsistent Form Reflects the Turmoil at Old Trafford | Manchester United

Football Aston Villa Manchester United Sport

Manchester United’s commercial power is often portrayed as largely unaffected by results on the pitch. Revenue continues to flow because the organisation has grown into a global giant, moving far beyond its origins as a football club and turning into an endless drama filled with twists that even fictional television characters might struggle to match.

The story features unpopular billionaire owners, a manager facing mounting pressure, and Diogo Dalot cast as the chief villain, alongside developments that increasingly defy belief. Yet behind the larger personalities are more ordinary failings that have dragged United down to 18th in the Premier League and left Michael Carrick uncertain about how long he can remain in charge.

United found themselves two goals down inside four minutes and needing another remarkable recovery after their midweek Champions League comeback against Roma. This side now displays more determination and frustration than it did earlier in the campaign, with Matheus Cunha providing both quality and intensity. From the second goal until half-time, the hosts produced an impressive collective response, although Dalot was again exposed when Alysson broke through and narrowly missed shortly before the interval.

Dalot represents one element of a much wider issue. He is an unconvincing right-back being asked to operate on the opposite flank because the club failed to recruit adequate cover for the frequently injured Luke Shaw. Supporters directed angry chants at football director Jason Wilcox, blaming him in part for a defensive unit that has already allowed 30 goals in all competitions, matching the worst total among clubs in Europe’s five leading leagues.

The Portuguese defender has spent more than eight years at Old Trafford, but his extended stay has only reinforced doubts about whether he meets the required standard. Each appearance seems to add another avoidable error to the record of a player regarded as experienced. He drifts out of position so regularly that an unfamiliar viewer might assume he is supposed to be playing on the wing or in central midfield.

He also shared responsibility for Roma’s two goals after repeatedly losing his positional awareness. United escaped punishment by completing their comeback, giving the coaching staff an opportunity to correct both the tactical setup and Dalot’s interpretation of the full-back role. Instead, less than a minute into this contest, he hesitated over whether to close down Alysson near the penalty area. By standing off, he gave the Brazilian space to shoot through Senne Lammens’ legs and punish another damaging mistake.

Although Alysson only moved to England in January, the 20-year-old already appears comfortable at Premier League level. He consistently outplayed Dalot for as long as they faced one another.

Recovering to 2-2 was a notable achievement, and United appeared to have taken control. However, Harry Maguire did not return for the second half, leaving Dalot with additional defensive responsibility alongside Ayden Heaven. Despite earning 40 international caps for a strong European nation, Dalot showed little composure when he brought down Alysson in the penalty area, giving John McGinn the opportunity to shift the contest back in Villa’s direction.

Carrick finally ended Dalot’s afternoon in the 66th minute, signalling the substitution from the touchline. Under the updated regulations, the defender had to leave quickly, jogging off within 10 seconds after a deeply disappointing display. United supporters applauded the decision to replace him with Patrick Dorgu. It was hardly a dramatic succession, but the crowd had clearly run out of patience with a familiar source of frustration.

At most clubs, Dalot’s recurring mistakes would have cost him his place, but United lack credible alternatives throughout the squad. A single victory from 10 league games has left them deservedly inside the relegation places after more than a quarter of the campaign. Dalot reflects the club’s deeper weaknesses: despite dreadful results, almost nobody among the substitutes, other than teenager Shea Lacey, is making a convincing case to start.

It is uncomfortable to see one player singled out by tens of thousands of supporters, particularly when Dalot is being used to represent failures that extend far beyond him. He should not be deployed at left-back and arguably should no longer be at the club after such a prolonged period of inadequate performances. United, however, have repeatedly lacked the ruthlessness required to move ineffective players on. Without his errors, the team’s task would have been far more manageable. Another late recovery produced celebrations at the final whistle, but the outcome could not reasonably be considered a victory.

What do you feel about this post?

0%
like

Like

0%
love

Love

0%
happy

Happy

0%
haha

Haha

0%
sad

Sad

0%
angry

Angry