Enzo Maresca did not appear entirely confused by Saturday’s loss to Nottingham Forest, but he was clearly frustrated. After opening the season with seven consecutive victories, his team have now suffered three defeats in a row. Such a sequence has occurred only once before in the history of England’s top division, when Sheffield Wednesday experienced it in 1904-05. Maresca argued that each loss unfolded differently, though his side recorded more possession and created more opportunities in all three matches.
During the 2-1 loss at Aston Villa two weeks earlier, City controlled 63% of possession and produced 15 attempts compared with Villa’s eight. In the following weekend’s 1-0 home defeat against Brighton, they held 62% of the ball and registered 21 chances to seven. At the City Ground, their possession reached 79%, while the chance count was 12 to 11. From that perspective, Maresca can reasonably suggest his team were unlucky. Forest, however, could respond that they entered the match third in the expected-goals standings but second from bottom in the actual table.
Another figure should be far more troubling for Maresca: City have not recorded a clean sheet since winning at Anfield after the previous international break, nine matches ago. They had also conceded three times against Sunderland in the game immediately before that victory. Across their latest eight fixtures, City have allowed 17 goals. Three of those strikes were influenced, at least partly, by mistakes from Gianluigi Donnarumma, but the broader problems are structural. Forest punished City’s weakness during defensive transitions, an issue that has appeared in Maresca’s previous teams. At Leicester and Chelsea, he was sometimes criticized for making his sides overly careful with the ball, yet that caution is understandable because of his preference for an aggressive defensive line.
Individual battles are therefore essential within Maresca’s approach, as surrendering possession can instantly leave the advanced back four exposed. He was visibly unhappy with the way Forest overpowered City during the first half. Once the ball is lost, opponents can attack the defense directly while exploiting the open ground behind it. That threat becomes even greater when facing a striker such as Liam Delap, who appears to have rediscovered his confidence and is eager to make up for more than a year of disappointing performances.
However, Maresca selected a midfield that always looked susceptible to being physically dominated. His admiration for Enzo Fernández is evident, with City spending £125m ($167.7m) to recruit him from Chelsea. Fernández possesses considerable technical quality, but he is not particularly powerful by Premier League standards. When he featured alongside Cole Palmer, Chelsea’s midfield sometimes appeared too lightweight. Maresca was nevertheless determined to include the Argentina international and devised complicated tactical arrangements to accommodate him, including deploying Malo Gusto in an unusual role combining right-back duties with those of a No 10.
City are now encountering comparable difficulties. Rayan Cherki is an exceptionally talented attacking midfielder, but his defensive positioning and commitment to tracking runners cannot always be trusted, as Pep Guardiola admitted last season. He can also be overwhelmed physically. Those shortcomings would be less damaging with two energetic midfielders behind him, ideally a mobile player in the style of Elliot Anderson alongside a disciplined holding midfielder or ball-winner such as Rodri. With Rodri no longer available and Fernández offering limited physical support, Anderson is left carrying much of that burden. If he is caught out of position—perhaps because a defender gives the ball away in a dangerous area or an opponent’s counterattack moves beyond him—City can become exposed almost immediately.
Maresca said he intends to use the international break to reconsider his approach, adding that this is one of the rare occasions when an immediate match might not be the best way to recover from defeat. A tactical answer may exist, and it could involve more than simply separating Fernández and Cherki. Nevertheless, Maresca must recognize that City may be out of the title contest by the time league football resumes, while developments away from the pitch could even threaten their place in the competition.
During the previous international break, an independent panel announced that City had been found guilty of every charge brought by the Premier League except one. Some observers believe the resulting punishment could be revealed during the current pause. It is almost impossible to determine exactly how the possibility of a major points deduction is affecting the squad. However, if the players’ original determination has turned into weary resignation, that uncertainty could help explain their reduced intensity, weakened motivation and failure to compete in crucial moments.
The difficulties are tactical, but tactics may not be the only cause.
What do you feel about this post?
Like
Love
Happy
Haha
Sad
