Bogle was extremely fortunate not to receive a card.
The incident unfolded in unusual fashion. Bogle was shaping his body to challenge Tel with his right foot, but as he attempted to set his left foot, he stepped on the Tottenham player’s ankle.
At normal speed, the contact appeared harmless, which likely explains why referee Brooks awarded the foul without showing a card.
However, slow-motion footage revealed the severity of the contact, particularly the way Tel’s ankle twisted.
Video official Tony Harrington could easily have asked Brooks to examine the incident on the pitchside monitor for a possible red card.
Harrington took an excessive amount of time to assess the footage, perhaps because Tel was still receiving treatment. Lengthy checks, however, often create unnecessary uncertainty about the decision-making process.
Harrington eventually informed Brooks that the original decision not to issue a red card would stand. He noted that Bogle entered the incident without significant speed and stepped into the contact, concluding that it was a reckless challenge.
Reckless play normally warrants a yellow card, but the video official cannot intervene solely to recommend a booking for Bogle.
Harrington’s description of Bogle as stepping into the contact is also significant.
This does not automatically prevent a dismissal, but it makes a red-card review less likely because this type of action usually carries less force.
The incident also invites comparison with Mateta’s dismissal following a video review against Tottenham the previous week.
It could be argued that Mateta, who initially received a yellow card, used less force when making contact with Micky van de Ven’s ankle. The key distinction, though, lies in the type of challenge.
Mateta lunged and stretched toward the ball with his studs exposed, an action generally viewed as involving greater force and posing more danger to an opponent.
Even so, although Bogle did not appear to be attempting a conventional tackle, the severity of the contact may leave many believing that the incident deserved an official red-card review.
What do you feel about this post?
Like
Love
Happy
Haha
Sad
