Charlton’s Woes Reveal ‘Vast Gulf’ Between WSL and Women’s Championship | Charlton Women

Charlton Women Football Sport Women's Super League

Eight matches, eight defeats. Charlton Athletic’s arrival in the Women’s Super League has been unforgiving, with the newly promoted club at risk of being overwhelmed before dropping back into the second tier.

Still recovering from Sunday’s 6-0 loss to Chelsea, last season’s playoff champions are enduring a difficult start to life in the WSL. They are allowing more than three goals per match on average and finding it hard to compete with wealthier opponents. The question is whether Charlton are falling short or simply paying the price for achieving promotion earlier than expected.

Karen Hills’ side exceeded expectations last season, finishing ahead of better-funded second-tier rivals including Newcastle and Bristol City before defeating Leicester on penalties to earn promotion. Since then, however, there has been little cause for celebration. Sunday’s visit to second-bottom Crystal Palace, who also came up last season, may represent one of Charlton’s best chances to collect their first point.

Injuries have also worked against Charlton. Club-record signing Linda Líf Boama sustained a serious knee injury in September, while France defender Hawa Cissoko, recruited partly for her top-flight experience, is unavailable because of an ankle problem. The club clearly attempted to improve the squad, but the other promoted teams pursued more ambitious summer recruitment. Birmingham added two Manchester United players, while Palace brought in former Tottenham captain Bethany England and WSL2 leading scorer Lexi Lloyd-Smith.

Charlton suffered substantial financial losses while competing in WSL2. Accounts covering the year to 30 June 2025, submitted in October, showed that the women’s team lost £1.32m, carried net liabilities of £2.18m and required further financial support. Detailed figures for wages, revenue and spending were not disclosed because the company qualified for an audit exemption under section 479A of the Companies Act 2006.

Moving into the WSL creates further costs because clubs must satisfy stricter minimum standards and pay higher minimum wages. Last season in WSL2, the required minimum salary was £26,900 for players aged 23 or older, £22,200 for those aged 21 or 22, and £17,500 for players between 18 and 20. In the highest division, those figures increase to £42,500, £34,700 and £26,900 respectively.

Central funding remains limited. WSL Football’s 2024-25 accounts reported payments of £9.41m across its 24 member clubs, equal to roughly £400,000 per team. Unlike promotion in the men’s game, reaching the women’s top division does not immediately transform a club’s finances. Its main advantage is increased visibility through major broadcast coverage. Charlton also lack the financial backing of a wealthy owner connected to a men’s team.

There is a view within the women’s game that Charlton completed their summer recruitment too hastily. The club did not announce its first new arrival until 18 July. Birmingham, by comparison, had been planning for promotion much earlier, with head coach Amy Merricks repeatedly discussing the need to prepare for WSL football during the 2024-25 season.

Birmingham and Palace have both earned draws away to Arsenal this season and challenged several other opponents. Charlton, meanwhile, have become only the fifth team to lose their first eight WSL fixtures. They have found it especially difficult to retain possession, producing only six passing sequences of at least 10 passes and recording an average passing accuracy of just 65%. Nevertheless, all three promoted clubs are struggling with the higher standard, so their positions at the bottom of the table are not unexpected. Merricks, whose Birmingham side visit London City Lionesses on Sunday, believes the final standings could look very different, although she described the divide between the two leagues as enormous.

Hills said her players had prepared strongly during the week but acknowledged the scale of the task. She explained that Charlton are attempting to close the distance and remain competitive, while leading clubs continue to strengthen with superior players, finances and resources. The challenge is considerable, she added, and its difficulty becomes clearer with every passing week.

What do you feel about this post?

0%
like

Like

0%
love

Love

0%
happy

Happy

0%
haha

Haha

0%
sad

Sad

0%
angry

Angry