If its conclusions are eventually published in full, this could become one of the most closely watched reports in football. In September, the increasingly influential European Football Clubs organisation commissioned a “feasibility study” to explore how it might expand worldwide and evolve into a body representing clubs across the globe.
Some prominent figures in football administration believe the study could shape the sport’s future for decades. It may significantly alter a system already unsettled by controversies involving Fifa and Gianni Infantino. Once regarded mainly as a lobbying group defending clubs against powerful governing institutions, EFC has grown into an organisation with almost 1,000 members and may eventually challenge those institutions’ authority.
“The moment has arrived to establish World Football Clubs,” EFC chair Nasser Al-Khelaïfi told representatives at the organisation’s general assembly in Copenhagen seven weeks ago. People familiar with the initiative say its ambition to expand is both clear and understandable, especially because players and domestic leagues already have international representative organisations.
Critics, however, describe the plan as “a takeover by stealth” and worry that it could disguise an effort by Europe’s leading clubs to strengthen their control over football’s future direction.
People familiar with EFC’s plans say the organisation is considering entering the international football market as a tournament operator, including the possibility of creating more effective competitions in a variety of formats.
Such responsibilities traditionally belong to Fifa or regional bodies including Uefa and Concacaf. If major clubs can establish competitions of their own, however, they could secure commercial and financial rewards far greater than those currently available through the confederations.
The possibility has placed some established authorities on alert. “One of football’s major unspoken divisions is beginning to become visible,” a source says about the relationship between EFC and Uefa. Although the two organisations have developed closer structural ties in recent years, their dealings remain marked by considerable mutual caution. One observer describes the arrangement as keeping “friends close and enemies closer”.
That tension appears particularly important as different groups compete for influence following the collapse of Infantino’s Fifa Forward Enterprise proposal. Alongside a substantial rise in funding for member associations, several senior football officials believe the initiative’s failure will ultimately give Europe’s largest clubs even greater power.
The additional funding is already being distributed. Fifa announced last month that it would release another $2.7bn (£2.05bn) from its reserves during the next four years, raising its overall investment to $6.35bn (£4.83bn). The expected increase in club influence may soon follow.
EFC’s study is not the only project capable of reshaping football. Details disclosed in September indicated that EFC and Fifa had been developing a joint venture to manage the commercial operations of global club tournaments such as the Club World Cup. The fallout from FFE appears to have provided the momentum needed to advance the arrangement.
Several sources say the proposed partnership is prepared to move forward once Infantino gives his approval. It resembles the model used by Uefa and EFC to operate European club competitions since 2008, an arrangement formalised last year through the establishment of the commercial company UC3.
A person familiar with the discussions says Infantino had delayed the agreement until the FFE controversy emerged in July, after which negotiations progressed more quickly. The deal could be announced during next month’s Fifa Council meeting in Doha, although approval after the governing body’s presidential election in March is considered more probable.
The proposed joint venture has generated particular unease within Uefa. Senior officials there are understood to have warned against quickly completing an agreement between EFC and Fifa under the present circumstances.
Uefa has continued its forceful criticism of Infantino and is close to supporting a rival candidate in next year’s election. EFC, by contrast, has said little since its chief executive, Charlie Marshall, sent a strongly worded letter to Fifa secretary general Mattias Grafström on 31 July.
At that point, EFC firmly opposed FFE and reportedly threatened to withdraw from future Club World Cups and revoke its support for the international match calendar. The proposed sell-off was formally abandoned the next day.
One especially confrontational passage stated: “Unless a fully functioning Fifa-EFC CWC joint venture is created well before the women’s 2028 Fifa CWC rights cycle, with sole control over commercial, operational and related matters, EFC will neither support nor allow its member clubs to enter future editions, including the women’s and men’s tournaments in 2028 and 2029.”
Al-Khelaïfi did not directly discuss the dispute when he spoke in Copenhagen two months later, prompting suggestions that both sides had reached a beneficial compromise. The crisis may have enabled EFC to obtain its preferred terms. “The main issue is not whether Gianni wins the election, but the nature of his mandate and the groups supporting him,” a senior European football source said. “EFC forms a major part of that answer. It could gain influence over Fifa in much the same way it increased its power within Uefa. The largest clubs now possess even more authority and control.”
“EFC initially adopted a very aggressive position against Gianni but softened it rapidly. It has remained quiet about the presidential election and wider governance questions, which strongly suggests that an understanding with Fifa has been reached. The joint venture appears to be what it received in return for that silence.”
The agreement would probably accelerate changes that are already taking place. Europe’s biggest clubs are positioned to earn still more from new tournaments, particularly as those competitions are expected to become larger and more frequent, beginning with a 48-team men’s Club World Cup in 2029.
Chelsea collected $115m (£85m) after winning the first expanded edition last year. European teams occupied six of the top seven positions in the prize-money rankings, while Brazil’s Fluminense was the only club from outside Europe to receive more than $50m.
Solidarity funding also favours Europe. Its clubs are due to collect half of the $250m allocation despite accounting for only 12 of the tournament’s 32 participants. Supporters of the existing distribution model argue that Europe is responsible for roughly 70% of Fifa’s income.
A senior representative from another confederation said the partnership would inevitably leave the rest of the world with a smaller share of the available money. “The most important lasting effect of the Fifa crisis will be the further consolidation of the largest European clubs’ financial power,” the source said. “For everyone else, that will mean fewer opportunities to enter competitions and a reduced share of revenue and broadcasting rights.”
“European clubs are highly organised, make decisions based on clear financial interests and have used this situation to obtain concessions from Fifa. Gianni Infantino has built his approach around distributing money and may now direct substantial payments to clubs as well as national associations.”
Those consequences are relatively easy to anticipate. What remains harder to determine is how profoundly football could change if a future World Football Clubs organisation acquires the level of authority many observers believe it is seeking.
“Clubs everywhere should have representation, a meaningful voice and a stronger opportunity to prosper,” Al-Khelaïfi said in September. Even so, football’s richest clubs appear better placed than any other group to profit from the sport’s current turmoil.
What do you feel about this post?
Like
Love
Happy
Haha
Sad
