In retrospect, the two days leading up to United’s opening fixture at Hull proved crucial.
Benjamin Sesko was still working his way back from the shin problem that prematurely ended his previous season when Amad Diallo sustained an ankle injury that sidelined him for seven weeks. Carrick consequently lost his preferred alternative up front and had to deploy Bryan Mbeumo on the right side of the attack.
Carrick opted for Matheus Cunha instead, but the forward’s tendency to move into deeper areas brought him into the same positions usually occupied by captain Bruno Fernandes.
That overlap blunted United’s attacking threat, while the team appeared unprepared for the physical intensity of opponents inspired by their long-awaited return to the Premier League.
Former Norway and Middlesbrough forward Jan Aage Fjortoft, working as an interviewer for Nordic broadcaster Viaplay, later suggested United had shown insufficient desire. Carrick rejected that assessment as “ridiculous”.
“It is only one match,” Carrick told reporters afterward.
A week later, United fell behind against another newly promoted team, Ipswich. A mistake by Marcelino Nunez in his own half enabled Cunha to create an opportunity for Fernandes, who scored an equaliser United had done little to deserve.
The Portuguese midfielder, recently named the PFA Player of the Year for 2025-26, subsequently completed a hat-trick as United secured a 5-2 victory.
Since then, his only league goal has been the penalty he converted against Villa on Sunday.
United followed the Ipswich victory with an away fixture at Everton.
The visitors went ahead twice, with substitute Sesko restoring their advantage two minutes before the end. However, Ainsley Maitland-Niles struck from distance deep into added time to prevent United from taking all three points.
When questioned about his confidence in the team’s capacity to recover from an underwhelming opening to the campaign, Carrick replied sharply: “It hasn’t been as poor as that.”
The results that followed told a more troubling story.
Concerns about United’s conditioning continued to surface. They laboured against Manchester City even after their opponents were reduced to 10 players during the first half, before Erling Haaland scored a goal that refereeing chief Howard Webb later acknowledged should have been disallowed.
Carrick had legitimate grounds for complaint, although the disputed decision also diverted attention from his team’s disappointing display.
United raced into a 2-0 advantage within 10 minutes of their EFL Cup tie against Brighton, only to lose control of the contest and suffer defeat after conceding twice in a four-minute spell during the second half.
The narrow moments that had favoured United during Carrick’s temporary spell in charge were now working against them, and the coaching team praised only months earlier was unable to reverse the decline.
Carrick viewed Cunha’s added-time equaliser against bottom-placed Fulham as a foundation for improvement. Yet United drew again immediately after the international break, allowing a struggling Tottenham side with 10 players to level in stoppage time.
The pressure surrounding the club was rapidly intensifying.
Lisandro Martinez, who had put through his own net against Fulham, was responsible for Tottenham’s equaliser. That made his reaction following the 2-0 Champions League loss to Atletico Madrid even more striking.
The Argentine defender questioned United’s summer transfer activity and directed responsibility toward “the technical director”, Wilcox.
By the time Martinez made those remarks, both Sesko and left-back Luke Shaw were unavailable through injury, while Marcus Rashford had also stopped featuring. Carrick’s constant reshuffling at left-back was already underway and eventually resulted in five different players starting in that position.
Having conceded during the opening minute against Atletico, United then allowed Como to score inside two minutes on the way to a 4-1 Champions League defeat. Fernandes publicly questioned Carrick’s tactical approach after the match.
Fernandes was left out against Bournemouth before returning as captain for the trip to Chelsea, but United lost both fixtures.
With United having collected only three victories from 15 matches across all competitions this season and sitting 18th in the Premier League, Carrick appears likely to face the consequences.
What do you feel about this post?
Like
Love
Happy
Haha
Sad
